Which apps to keep, replace or remove
Most stores I look at run apps that made sense the year they went in. Some still earn their place. Some do a job Shopify now does for free. A few do nothing at all. This guide gives you four questions to ask of every app, so you can sort the list yourself.
The four questions for every app
- What does it cost each month? Your Shopify admin lists every app's charges under Settings → Billing. Count usage fees and per-order fees too, not just the subscription.
- What does it add to your pages? Some apps load files on every page a shopper opens, even pages where the app does nothing. The Self-check shows you how to count them for one app in two minutes.
- Can Shopify do this job itself? Shopify adds features every year. Subscriptions, bundles, product filters and simple discounts all have Shopify versions now. An app you added in 2021 may be doing a job your store already has for free.
- Will it still work after March 1 and April 1, 2027? From March 1, Shopify stops loading code that older apps add to your pages the old way, and the features it runs stop showing. From April 1, App Store apps that haven't made a security update Shopify requires stop working, and Shopify warns you in your admin first. To find out which of yours are affected, ask each app's support team, or have a Store Audit check them all. If an app is going to stop, it's a good moment to decide whether you'd replace it anyway.
Apps that usually stay
Email and SMS, loyalty programs, help desks, and subscription apps that do something Shopify's own subscriptions app doesn't. Their value is in the service behind them: the email list, the points balance, the support history. Replacing the app would mean rebuilding that service, which rarely pays. If one of them slows your pages, the fix is usually how it loads, not the app itself.
The call is free, and you decide afterward.
Apps that are often worth replacing
Apps that mostly display something on your pages: review stars and review lists, store locators, bundle offers, page builders, countdown banners. The job is simple, the monthly fee never ends, and the files they load can slow every product page.
"Worth replacing" depends on your numbers. Add up what the app costs over three years at your store's volume, then compare it with a one-time build and its upkeep. If the build costs less, you can work out the month it pays for itself. If it costs more, keep the app, unless it measurably slows your pages and you decide that's worth paying for.
You can keep the useful part of an app and drop the rest. A review app can go on collecting and moderating reviews while your product pages show them without the app's widget.
Code nothing uses any more
Uninstalling an app doesn't always clean up after it. Tracking code pasted into the theme years ago, edits from past developers and code from older apps can stay behind and still load. It's usually a short list. Taking it out needs care, because some of it may still feed a report someone relies on.
Doing it yourself, or getting it done
You can answer questions 1 and 4 from your admin, and question 2 for one app at a time with the Self-check. The App cost calculator adds up what all your apps cost over three years.
Question 3, and measuring every app at once, is where a Store Audit helps. I go through every app and script your store loads, measure what each one does to your pages on phones, and give you a verdict for each: keep, replace or remove. It costs $500, $1,000 or $1,500 depending on your store, with a written report within 7 business days, and you can act on it with your own developer or with me.