An image depicting a multitude of blue question marks, intricately stacked on top of each other, creating a visually striking pattern.

Confusing Meal Plan Options & Customization Limitations

Is your website littered with abandoned carts, especially on your meal plan page? The culprit might be overly complex customization options that leave customers frustrated and confused. In this guide, we'll show you how to streamline your Shopify setup for clear choices. By simplifying the selection process, you'll empower customers to create perfect meal plans that meet their needs, leading to happier, repeat customers who are more likely to convert and keep your business thriving.

Why Confusing Customizations Kill Meal Prep Sales

Customers who land on your meal plan page are excited about delicious, healthy meals made easy. Confusing setups can quickly bombard people and turn their excitement into frustration.

These confusing setups are more than just a problem in the meal prep niche. Studies show that across e-commerce, too many choices can lead to decision paralysis, making customers less likely to complete a purchase. 

This hesitation is especially true for meal prep. Unlike buying a t-shirt, customers must decide about dietary restrictions, portion sizes, and meals that appeal to them. A confusing customization process adds another layer of complexity, often resulting in abandoned carts and lost revenue.


Ready to see how I can help? Book a free consultation to discuss your meal plan setup.  


Let's imagine a few scenarios to illustrate how this happens:

Streamlining Meal Prep Customizations for Success

A photo of a satisfied female customer enjoying her meal prep.

Mistake #1: The Overwhelming Options Buffet

The Problem:

Imagine yourself as a hungry customer excited to order your week's worth of healthy meals. But instead of feeling empowered to customize, you're bombarded with a dizzying array of options (sides, sauces, substitutions, etc). Suddenly, the task feels overwhelming instead of convenient.

You have too many choices at each stage (base meal, sides, add-ons, etc.) and find yourself facing a list of 10+ potential add-ons. On top of it all, the pricing structure is unclear, leaving you unsure how these choices will impact the final total. This overload leads to abandoned carts and frustrated customers.

Why It's Confusing:

  • Decision Fatigue: Each add-on might SEEM like a good thing, but mentally, every choice depletes our decision-making energy. This decision fatigue is especially true for food, where preferences are highly personal.
  • Pricing Unclear: When the pricing feels unpredictable, two things happen: Customers either abandon their cart out of fear of a shocking total, OR they reluctantly place the order, harboring resentment, which isn't ideal for repeat business.


  • Tiered Plans: A few curated bundles (e.g., "Vegetarian Delight," "High Protein," "Fitness," "Family-Style," etc.) provide clear starting points. Customers can still personalize from there, but the initial decision is simpler, reducing that initial overwhelm.
  • Visual Pricing: Charts or clear pricing are displayed next to each option, so the cart total updates dynamically. This clear pricing builds trust and empowers customers to make informed decisions.
  • App Recommendations or Custom Solutions: If you have many valid combinations for your meal prep model, consider finding Shopify apps or custom solutions that can streamline how you present those choices. The goal is to make customization intuitive, unlike a complex puzzle.

Additional Tip: The Power of Smart Defaults

Pre-select popular add-ons (extra protein on certain meals, etc.) and allow customers to remove them. This eases decision fatigue while potentially boosting average order value.

Need help implementing these changes? My Shopify expertise can transform your meal plan experience.

Mistake #2: Vague Descriptions & Hidden Restrictions

The Problem:

  • Beyond Vague Descriptions: Customers don't just want to know the dish's name. They want to envision themselves eating it. Are the vegetables roasted for sweetness or lightly steamed? Is the sauce spicy or mild? These details matter! Think of this in terms of missed opportunities. 
  • Limitations as Frustrations: Restrictions are a reality of meal prep, but they shouldn't feel like surprises. When a customer discovers their choices are invalid only at checkout, it erodes the trust you've worked to build.

Why It's Confusing:

  • Lack of Specificity = Lack of Confidence: Customers hesitate to commit without detailed descriptions. They might worry that a "Southwest Chicken Bowl" is too spicy for their kids or that "Seasonal Veggie Stir-fry" contains disliked ingredients.
  • Hidden Restrictions = Damaged Reputation: If the restriction is not visible during the selection process, customers may feel misled, even if it is mentioned somewhere on your site. This lack of visibility leads to negative reviews and hesitancy to reorder.


  • Ingredient Transparency: Don't just list ingredients. Sell the dish! "Crunchy walnuts, maple-glazed carrots, quinoa with fresh herbs..." This paints a delicious picture in their minds.
  • Visual Cues: Photos are essential, and not just of the final dish. Simple icons representing dietary needs build trust immediately for those with allergies or preferences.
  • Upfront Restrictions: Make those limitations work for you by presenting them clearly alongside the options. This clarity shows customers you value their time and minimizes frustration.

Additional Note:

Accessibility: Screen readers for visually impaired customers often struggle with image-only information. Clear text descriptions and alt-text are not just good UX. They make your site inclusive.

Mistake #3: When the Customization Process Itself is the Obstacle (Expanded)

The Problem:

  • Beyond Visual Clutter: A cluttered interface isn't just about aesthetics; it's a functional nightmare for customers. When information is hard to find, crucial options get overlooked, and the steps to build a meal feel like a maze, it creates a frustrating experience that can drive customers away.
  • Inconsistent Terminology: Inconsistency in language throughout the website can be confusing and erode customer trust. Are your "add-ons" suddenly referred to as "extras" on the checkout page? Do different pages use different terms for the same concept? These inconsistencies can create hesitation and uncertainty in the customer's mind.
  • Unclear Navigation: Can customers easily move back and forth between steps? Can they review their meal choices before finalizing the order? Lack of clear navigation forces users to start over or abandon the process entirely.

Why It's Confusing:

  • Cognitive Overload: Every time a customer has to pause and decipher your site's layout or terminology, it disrupts their thought process. Customization should feel effortless and intuitive, allowing them to focus on building their perfect meal.
  • Lack of Confidence: A confusing interface creates doubt and insecurity in the customer's mind. They might question if they've selected the right options, worry about hidden fees, or wonder if their order will be correct. This lack of confidence can lead to abandoned carts and lost sales.


  • Design for Simplicity: Embrace white space, use clear headings and concise descriptions, and guide users through the process with visual cues (arrows, progress bars). Simplicity doesn't mean boring; it means removing obstacles to a smooth ordering experience.
  • Shopify Best Practices: Shopify's built-in features and themes are designed with e-commerce psychology in mind. Leverage their intuitive layouts, standard terminology, and user-friendly checkout process to create a familiar experience for your customers.
  • User Testing: Get feedback from real people (friends, family, potential customers) who can test your customization flow. Their insights will help you identify and fix usability issues you might have overlooked.
  • Mobile-First Design: Remember, many customers order meals on their phones. Ensure your customization process is just as smooth and intuitive on mobile devices as it is on desktops.
  • Speed Optimization: A slow website, especially during customization, can be incredibly frustrating. Optimize your site speed to prevent delays and keep the process flowing.

Additional Mistake: Lack of Personalization

  • Problem: Meal prep businesses cater to diverse dietary needs and preferences. If customization options feel generic or limited, customers won't feel understood.
  • Solution: Offer personalized options like ingredient swaps, portion adjustments, and dietary filters. Consider using a meal builder app that allows customers to create their own unique combinations.

By addressing these common culprits, you can create a user-friendly, confidence-inspiring customization experience that drives meal prep sales and fosters customer loyalty.

Overwhelmed by Customizations? Let's Discuss a Shopify Solution Tailored to Your Meal Prep Business

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.